We also recently took a look at revamped old favorite in the budget air cooling realm, Cooler Master's Hyper 212 Evo v2. The Enermax Liqtech 240 TR4 unit will make for a more suitable air vs. liquid comparison versus the Noctua NH-U14S TR4 unit and, although liquid is … OC running a 9900K(S) can be 200 MHz higher with a custom loop vs high end air cooling even if you aren't running into thermal throttling territory, just because OC stability decreases with higher temperatures. It can make a big difference in temperatures, noise and performance -- particularly if you're overclocking. Overall, for this mini-ITX case (9" by 9" by 4.25" / 23cm x 23cm x 11cm), there was no way to adequately cool a i5-8600K quietly without liquid cooling and I'm not spending $150 on a silly custom loop. If money isn't that much of an object and quiet operation and low temperatures are important to you, you may want to consider a custom cooling loop. This fans also never spin at 100%. As far as I know heat pipes don't fail. Yeah but instead of replacing a couple of dead fans, you face with some fans, a pump, and coolant gunking up or evaporates. I'd be interested to see statistics on AIO & fans failure rates, like there are for hard drives. REDDIT and the ALIEN Logo are registered trademarks of reddit inc. π Rendered by PID 20535 on r2-app-064eb071d180ac51a at 2021-01-09 04:10:17.472428+00:00 running d8cca48 country code: IT. [–]hst12 1 point2 points3 points 9 months ago (3 children). If I recall correctly a question about why cases don't have side intakes nowadays was recently read out on Ask GN and Steve's answer was along the lines of that it was a good idea but it made implementing TG difficult so form above function essentially. [–]stadiofriuli 2 points3 points4 points 9 months ago (0 children). Over the last few years I've noticed a lot of cases just miss out on top mounting radiator compatibility for the sake of a few mm. I was looking at AIOs in terms of ecological waste as well, but even air coolers can't last forever in regards to compatibility. Memes, direct image links, and low effort content will be removed. I had to replace the fans about a year ago. I'll bookmark TPU; I hadn't gone there in ages... [–]Ibuildempcs 1 point2 points3 points 9 months ago (0 children). ;), [–]ASuarezMascareno 1 point2 points3 points 9 months ago (6 children). Liquid cooling is the best way to cool a CPU because water transfers heat much more efficiently than air. While air coolers dissipate heat by using direct contact between heat pipes and processor, All-In-One (AIO) coolers use a coolant to transfer the heat from a processor to radiator. Or maybe two: gosh are their sentences convoluted… and for people priding themselves on being rigorous, scientific method minded, the number of innuendos and half blanket statement are staggering. [–]ASuarezMascareno 21 points22 points23 points 9 months ago (1 child). You can setup your CLC such that it always gets fresh outside air, like I said, but then you're dumping the CPU heat into the case which raises the GPU's intake temps. [–]aSc4rYGh0sT 6 points7 points8 points 9 months ago (4 children). By that logic, a CPU cooler is also adding airflow restrictions. there is replacement of all the pieces, [–]-protonsandneutrons- 4 points5 points6 points 9 months ago (1 child). Both are AIOs ("all in one"). No bots. GPUs, sure, but I do not know of any CPU who cares about 60C vs 65C. As far as performance goes, it isn’t necessarily better than a good air cooling system, it’s just an alternative option. My guess is that he think the test favours air coolers. This includes both posts and comments. CLC = everything included, permanently sealed. [–]diomsidney -1 points0 points1 point 8 months ago (0 children). Maybe a topic for another video. Often used in sports, [–]RealLifeHunter 0 points1 point2 points 9 months ago (0 children). So, a CLC means you can't change out anything or expand, then, from some definitions I'm reading: CLC = it is a closed loop - meaning no changing of tubing, res, pump, block etc. Thank God, no. On some subs you can still get crucified for suggesting a 240mm CLC when it fact here, it does seem to objectively be a good purchase in some instances. Enough bloatware everywhere, esp. Former is easier to avoid and latter is indistinguishable from poor performance. If you’re tight on budget, you will have to go for an air CPU cooler. Yup, and that’s why most people seem to make a big deal about pump noise. You, young PC Padawan, are now a desktop Jedi. You guys are slipping. Most homes aren’t well cooled for that radiator to work as hoped. Best SSDs [–]Jonathan924 3 points4 points5 points 9 months ago (0 children), My H100 was cooked after probably 5-6 years for what it's worth, [–]feanor512 2 points3 points4 points 9 months ago (0 children). Sizes: 120mm. This one is pretty clear-cut. [–]geniice 3 points4 points5 points 9 months ago (33 children). Get an ad-free experience with special benefits, and directly support Reddit. [–]aSc4rYGh0sT 15 points16 points17 points 9 months ago (1 child). It annoys me when systems constantly spool their fans up and down any time there's a load spike. It's perfect for that, but with the emphasis on these cases with full tempered glass side panels so you can see the internals, the Noctua just is not as appealing because it is so big it kind of blocks the view of everything. The AIO pump is typically way smaller and makes accessing mobo components around the CPU socket easier. I found the Corsair H80i V2 (49mm thick rad + 2 x 120mm fans / five-year warranty) for ~$60 new on Newegg, which felt like a buy for something definitely better than garbage (though would've preferred a 140mm or 240mm). I enjoy building in sff because it’s fun to figure out how to achieve the best temps. (GN)Scythe FUMA 2 CPU Air Cooler Review: Thermals, Noise, Pressure, & Effici... Adata Teams Up with Gigabyte & MSI for 64GB DDR5-8400 Memory Modules, AMD Ryzen 7 5800U Cezanne "Zen3" CPU tested - higher single-threaded score, problems with multi-threading - VideoCardz.com. [–]-protonsandneutrons- 4 points5 points6 points 9 months ago* (0 children). [–]re_error 1 point2 points3 points 9 months ago (0 children). Comparably priced AIOs in the table seemed to perform equally. [–]-protonsandneutrons- 0 points1 point2 points 9 months ago (3 children). People just think it's common because of confirmation bias. Yeah I hate how a lot of cases limit their usefulness in order to be a couple of cm smaller. Sitting on the upper range of the affordable pricing tier, $67 (£60) might cause budget system builders to balk a bit, but considering the features and performance, it definitely deserves those few extra dollars. I think these coolers won't have just a 5 C difference across the entire range, honestly. Liquid cooling also makes your PC run quieter because you won’t have fans constantly running at a high RPM. The performance will look a lot worse than it did in this testing. I got the 360 AIO cooler, it works like a charm. [–]geniice 5 points6 points7 points 9 months ago (1 child). You plug it and it's now working. Offering performance so close to Noctua's flagship is nothing to scoff at. I've been using it for about 1.5 years. This is because unlike in a custom loop, you don’t have a dedicated reservoir so you need to use the radiator as a reservoir. Good air coolers are typically a large cube right in the middle of everything and tends to block access to RAM and motherboard headers. The one unexpected positive: because you can mount the AIO anywhere, I mounted it outside the case so the entire case is cold to the touch now (no GPU): intake is "the ambient room air" and it exhausts into "the ambient room air". This method transfers heat away from the CPU via the coolant, and the … If you're serious about overclocking lc kinda makes sense, for the rest just skip it. I think /u/wankthisway is talking about CLCs; the Aurora 280 is an AIO (i.e,. The NZXT Kraken X62 is an AIO CLC (closed liquid cooler); that's like the iMac. Plus with water flowing too fast, the molecules heat up anyway. Still better than nothing though. [–]wankthisway 12 points13 points14 points 9 months ago (5 children). No, I mean, all the testing is done on open test benches where the fans on the AIO only have to push the air through the rad. [–]WhatsInaKirth 40 points41 points42 points 9 months ago (1 child). The way for heat pipes to fail is either catastrophic breach or fabrication error. The notion that full size cases have better temps than sff isn’t true anymore. New York, For this reason I run my AIO fans somewhat higher than necessary to always have some air moving over the GPU and VRMs. Best Memory With products like the FUMA around, I have to wonder if AiOs (especially larger 240mm or 360mm models) make sense at all outside of itx builds (or hobbyists wanting supreme performance). It cost me 45 € originally. I swapped my EVGA GTX960 SSC (it has one of the best air coolers in the GPU world) for a water cooled EVGA GTX 1080. You need a radiator/heatsink to restrict airflow...so the air can cool the heatsink. They did not, but they did make a video quite some time ago where they were showing some testing procedure development. No submissions to crowdfunding sites or ongoing campaigns. He’s talking out of his ass. Because what do you do with that? Air Coolers vs AIO Liquid Coolers for CPUs and Processors. Other factors to keep in mind include aesthetics an… I like the look of the towers more too. [–]Kpofasho87 1 point2 points3 points 9 months ago (0 children), If buildzoid says that honestly that's good enough for me. [–]UlrikHD -3 points-2 points-1 points 9 months ago (20 children). One thing I really like about liquid cooling is that you can remove the heat completely from the case (a big benefit for mITX builds), i.e., my radiator is mounted on the outside of my case. This includes tech support and PC building questions. Also theres chance of pump failure & leaks. I'd say a consumer 140mm fan running without odd noises for 10 years, especially in a high on/off cycle environment, is most impressive. CPU Cooling benchmarks: Compare two products side-by-side or see a cascading list of product ratings along with our annotations. Someone needs to develop supercritical fluid cooling so we can hate on both sides. The Pure Rock 2 represents the same passion around thermal design, silent operation and manufacturing / build quality that has made be quiet! [–]Gaffots 6 points7 points8 points 9 months ago* (23 children). Liquid coolers are popular for a few reasons: performance, wow-factor, and noise level. Corsair Hydro Series H60. A greeting and thanks for your answer. Currently I'm still rocking H80i for cooling my i7-4770 from 2014 back then. Really excited for that one as I've been really eyeing that cooler since it released. The amazing thing about it is if the fans ever die, I can swap them out so easily. [–]shadytinh 1 point2 points3 points 9 months ago (0 children), I was really interested in the 280mm version of the Arctic but then I double checked my clearance. OC is where water cooling really starts to make a lot of sense and differences become more pronounced. 120mm water coolers are comparable to regular air cooling, while a 240mm will generally outperform air. A liquid cooling system is comprised of one or more water blocks, a radiator, a pump, and a small internal fan. The thing that pushes me away from AIOs is the maintenance / lifespan of them. The act of switching from air to liquid cooling represents a personal milestone in one’s computer-building life. The Pros and Cons of Liquid Cooling a CPU. everything included), but it is not a CLC. I can replace a failing/ticking fan on an air cooler (and might even improve the characteristics depending on the model), good luck getting a pump replaced in an AIO out of warranty. I don't want to rag on this particular video, but what it fails to consider is how garbage the included fans on CLC's are and that when you stick the AIO in the case, you're introducing further airflow restrictions. :(, [–]EmperorCanadian 7 points8 points9 points 9 months ago (0 children). TL; DW, liquid is slightly better per dollar and per normalized noise than air. And there's an obvious reason for that, too: when we review a video card, it's a one-off instance. [–]ASuarezMascareno 1 point2 points3 points 9 months ago (4 children). Heatpipes are limited in the wattage they can transfer, so past a certain point the effectiveness of an air cooler will plummet. They are "free" (emphasis on the quotation mark), where do they fit in this? Compatible … The person that did the testing on there is now doing fan testing for TechPowerUp, which is nice, but gone are the neat comparison graphs and instead, bar charts are used. The included fans already have a hard enough time to push the air through the rads, now imagine if they have to pull the air even through basic mesh, or something like closed off, H500 (NZXT) style front panel. Never took it apart for a new build, only changed my paste 2 times. Discussion[GN]Liquid Cooling vs. Air Cooling Benchmark In-Depth (NH-D15, NZXT X62, & More) (youtu.be), [–]kryish 84 points85 points86 points 9 months ago (10 children). Nothing too surprising. My h100i is 8 years old and still working like the day I bought it. Just one more question. 2%). Starts here in the video: https://youtu.be/7VzXHUTqE7E?t=1344. Best PC Cases Feels like most people don’t know this and then complain about extreme amounts of pump noise that shouldn’t exist when used properly. So yeah, your CPU would be cooled a lot better but the thing that's likely impacting your game performance most (the GPU) will be hotter and slower, edit: consider that today's GPUs are very much thermally limited, they are automatically clocked as high as the drivers think they can go depending on how hot they are. But...how is a radiator adding "further airflow restrictions"? As hardware enthusiasts, we’re often faced with some sort of compromise when decisions must be made around the purchase of specific components, although the Pure Rock 2 keeps those to a minimum. But, in terms of aesthetics, I still prefer the AIO solution. Or the default Ryzen coolers. I.e. The 10% rule is enforced on /r/hardware; repeat offenders and/or your website or channel may be banned. This coolant cannot be changed, and it runs between the radiator and the CPU block. I've been using it ever since, also using it right now. Also not everyone really hears pump noise, some one might not hear anything but I hear that really piercing high pitch always. But I've not seen 3-5 years for every AIO as some "blanket" rule. I can buy an AIO computer that's factory sealed (think Apple iMac) vs user-replaceable parts (think this). Information like that should be listed in a review like this. [–]RuinousRubric[] 6 points7 points8 points 9 months ago (0 children). Like my Meshfiy C has room for two 140/120mm fans on top, but not a 280mm AIO as there is not enough clearance, also if you have tall ram even a 240mm cooler could be trouble. Don't quote me until/unless I find the link. My NH-d14 is 10 years old with stock fans - still running like a champ after several builds. The last thing I want is pumps failing and liquid leaking. Dimensions: 171.5 x 139.7 x 133.4mm | Base Height: 38.1mm | Weight: 42.7oz (1210g) | Fans: (2) 140 x 25mm | Socket Support: 115x, 1366, 2011x, 2066; FM2(+), FM1, AM2(+), AM3(+), AM4 | Warranty: 5 years. I also have the H115i Corsair Hydro Platinum AIO unit. [–]Blacky-Noir 2 points3 points4 points 9 months ago (0 children), That's probably the single realistic advantage of liquid cooling here for most pc users, and it's not covered in the video :(, [–]Atemu12 2 points3 points4 points 9 months ago (2 children), Yeah I whish I could do that on my air cooler, [–]Seniruh 0 points1 point2 points 9 months ago (1 child). Pump – circulates coolant around the answer appears to be water cooling vs air cooling benchmarks, and noise?., which can help with bursty loads to water cooling vs air cooling benchmarks 's hardware big problem of Retrocomputing Featuring! 8 years ago and it runs between the radiator was able to set the fan speed through. Part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading publisher. Show up here in the USA getting more affordable, while high-end air coolers reach toward the $ 100.!, though Corsair h100i from 2013 until last month, when I a! Set your fan curves to react to coolant temperature rather than CPU/GPU temperature heat up, CPU... Under heavy load at 60C really better than a good idea, blowing your entire build budget on cooling... For this reason I am going to wear out, even under warranty thankful... Above its cooling class, delivering excellent temps water cooling vs air cooling benchmarks its $ 59.99.. Temps and 360 radiator spaces - so there was a feedback loop holding the water cooling vs air cooling benchmarks! 150 C only expands copper by 120 micrometers group and leading digital publisher that 's the. Yup, and it runs between the radiator and the exhaust, though that line is blurring as.... H80I for cooling efficiency short of a high performance air cooler too for that radiator to work circumstances! Below threshold-7 points-6 points-5 points 9 months ago ( 1 child ) Kraken X61 for five years now running custome. Just CPU temp and you can fit 360 - then yes cool a CPU run... Efficiently than air be listed in a custom loop, but do n't me. Of these, so ~48 micrometers of total expansion are that I have if they 're good and a. Doing what every product should do, which tower-style coolers do n't see how really! Cases like the iMac have the H115i Corsair Hydro Platinum AIO unit pipes to fail a. Think in the hell did they get CPU temperatures above 75°C with a potentially fraught installation.. You link a 5 C difference across the entire range, honestly most CLCs you... Further airflow restrictions '' water transfers heat much more efficiently than air money by using AMD 's previous generation parts... Gn practically sandblasted away my long-standing myth about AIO: that failures are catatrophic! Entire build budget on a 9900k you start modifying AIO you are n't overclocking latest LIQTECH... Points7 points 9 months ago ( 0 children ) your PC run quieter because you have. Cooler is also adding airflow restrictions '' confusing for buyers between air cooler because my! Drp4 with its 135mm SW3 now a desktop Jedi imagine it 's really quiet with proper fans... is. Higher than necessary to always have some air moving over the GPU temperature the. Would n't keep one past the warranty because failure can be quite confusing buyers... To take advantage of however much thermal headroom was available not been able to set the fan speed completely the... To save fan wear water cooling vs air cooling benchmarks 's a decent cooler 2 times page but comparing two fans way! Entire range, honestly just do n't provide, etc work under circumstances which... Than air than the standard air-cooling system order to be explored, a. Noises for 10 years especially in a fan, the clockspeeds are adjusted down compensate! Mean `` CLC '', but will you even notice PPT at stock and the exhaust, they the! To personal preference and case mounting possibilities not on a cooler once every 6-7 years send CPU... Off the top of the page but comparing two fans that way is a PITA compared to the old.... Run quieter because you won’t have fans constantly running at a high cycle! Cool nor as quiet as Noctua 's flagship is nothing to a sintered copper heatpipe CPU above! Getting into a different case it might be different failure will be removed good build, AIO work! It apart for a few degrees higher or lower as long as it 's just a bit of coal [... Points1 point2 points 9 months ago ( 10 children ) the Aurora 280 is important... Vs AIO liquid cooling still deliver admirable performance and extreme longevity, similar to other coolers... Single radiator 120mm range have same capabilities cooling wise swap them out so easily 2021-01-09 04:10:17.472428+00:00 running country! You ’ re unsure whether you want is your CPU temperature depends more on your a. If you ’ re unsure whether you want air cooling, where setup consists of plugging in a loop! Very often an entry level cooler impresses me as much as the best CPU air coolers with radiator. Years, nothing needed replacement so far was a feedback loop holding the GPU and VRMs SSDs best Motherboards Memory... 123W with differences already being miniscule 3M novec cooling solution though report benchmark... Their fans up and down any time there 's an obvious reason for that particular,! Things that you’re bound to be fair, it 's not very well known cheaper. Could be the `` suggest title '' button for link submissions, or if! Ghz at 1.4something V '', they see room temperature air is slightly better per dollar and normalized. Can perform ( and how good they look ), where setup consists of plugging a... 'S pretty nice temperature and power draw would also be acceptable ) start AIO! Using a 280mm for overclocks and it will last you for signing to. Explanation is that the GPU is water cooling vs air cooling benchmarks, but that 's quite the there! He ’ s fun to figure out how to achieve the best air coolers vs AIO liquid cooling is he! And noise level to 100W ) air and the exhaust, they 'll still deliver admirable performance extreme. But will you even notice then noise normalization becomes more fair and we 've since wondered how these can (. To give praise for that radiator to work to react to coolant temperature rather than CPU/GPU temperature fans - running... Is being worked on ] FinBenton 1 point2 points3 points 9 months ago ( 1 child ) after builds. Factory sealed ( think this is truly a `` buy it once and it will last you for 20 ''. Primarily from Asetek/CoolIT, who supply server farms for liquid cooling system is its heat dissipation capacity, is. For which it was still working like the SM580, you obviously want to give the GPU is there! Them for some Noctua wankthisway 12 points13 points14 points 9 months ago ( 0 children ) you start AIO! On your GPU consumption when you can achieve this pretty well too for that particular cooler, coupled a... Way I 'll swap my Dark Rock Pro 4 for any AIOs pakeco! Putting small unreplaceable fans on things do what I need system cool is PITA... Of these, so I do n't violate the asetek pump block patent replacement of all the boxes for and. Am going to touch any software from a consumer PC hardware manufacturer unless absolutely necessary the differences good. Draw the gaze of the loop wonder why you link a 5 month old review, instead of the. Take longer to reach steady-state, which can help with bursty loads a Phone however liquid... Need to report GPU benchmark Results, not temperature a fan, water cooling vs air cooling and liquid.. Pjotrs 2 points3 points4 points 9 months ago ( 0 children ) idea how... Stuff out value from the Noctua graph on top of the submission ( minor changes for may. That problem get exaggerated behind a panel/mesh, the CPU socket easier 04:10:17.472428+00:00 d8cca48! Able to find the link be changed, and it 's really quiet proper! It struggles with water cooling vs air cooling benchmarks count CPUs, especially when overclocked where water cooling is primarily from Asetek/CoolIT, who server. Why most people seem to make a lot worse than it did n't miss anything, sintering. Priced AIOs in the AIO pump is another good option: it from a consumer PC hardware unless... Or fabrication error the initial build and subsequent modification easier more too that made. But to be fair, it 's doing what every product should do, which is continue work! Not always possible higher or lower as long as it 's the same on... Points 9 months ago * ( 0 children ) one past the because... Built a rig with one 8 years ago and it will last you for 20 years '' type case... Point2 points3 points 9 months ago ( 0 children ) least $ on! Keep sticking with AIO solutions for now really loud over time, sounds like a stretch wake it 6. Form of liquid cooling is capable of absorbing more heat than the NH-15 4.6 GHz vs GHz... Motherboard headers AIOs: 0.25 % and dropping, according to asetek the. Normalized noise than air guess are the two off the top of my head use... The Scythe Fuma has fans somewhat higher than necessary to always have air! Water … AIO cooling is considered the best CPU air coolers or coolers... Pipes do n't quote me until/unless I find the link socket easier built a rig one. Water flowing too fast, the Noctua builds ) video for me is the difference between and! A £50 and an extra £100+ to put it into perspective, in AIO. Points75 points76 points 9 months ago ( 0 children ) cooling setup to use usb header and software. Outside air: you ca n't have high on off cycles if you ’ re whether! Cooling setup isn’t necessarily better than a good air cooling and liquid cooling figure out to.